Pre-Order Your Pie

Reserve the pie of your dreams!

Please note that Thanksgiving pies have a separate order form marked “Thanksgiving Pie Order Form”. For pickup the week of Thanksgiving, please use the Thanksgiving order form!

We bake fresh Monday through Saturday, and that means we can sell out pretty dang quick. When it's gone, it's gone for the day!

If you need to be sure a pie will be waiting for you, make sure to call ahead or use the form below to pre-order.

Just give us a call (573-447-7437) to let us know the size and flavor of pie you want when you'll be able to swing by. Then, come by the shop Monday through Saturday to pay and take home a few slices of love.

Please note: We cannot guarantee the availability of same-day pickups.

Or you can pre-order your pie without talking to anyone with this handy-dandy form!

Name *
Phone Number *
Phone Number
What size would you like? *
We do not offer gluten-free or pot pies in the 12 inch size!
What size for that second flavor?
We do not offer gluten-free 12-inch pies!
What date do you want these pies on? *
What date do you want these pies on?
Note: We cannot guarantee the availability of all flavors for same-day pickup. We are not open on Sundays and Mondays. You will only be able to pick up your pies on Tuesday through Saturday!
What time will you come pick your pies up? *
What time will you come pick your pies up?
I understand I cannot pick up pies on Sundays and that same-day pickup cannot be guaranteed. *

Pie sizes—how hungry are you?

9-inch Pies

Our 9-inch pies are great for sharing between a couple people. You can get about 6-8 slices from this pie, depending what a slice means to you. 

Baby Pies

This 5-inch pie is perfect for treating yourself. With only 1.5-2 slices, a Baby Pie doesn't even cheat your new diet.

12-inch Pies

Sharing is caring, and you won't mind so much with a 12-inch pie! Get 10-12 slices of goodness out of this big ol' pie.


These petite tarts are the smallest treats we offer in our shop. They're only 3-inches and cute as can be!

Don't forget: You'll be paying in store!

Still deciding which flavor to pre-order?