You might want to sit down for this.

Our selection of pies is extensive, but we're sure you'll find your favorite in no time.

We offer pies in a three-inch tart, a five-inch Baby (one to two slices), a nine-inch pie (six to eight slices) and a 12-inch size (10 to12 slices).


Tart (boxed): $2.50 each. Tart (bagged with ribbon): $3. Baby, Cream, Fruit, Speciality: $8. Nine-inch, Cream & Fruit: $18. Nine-inch, Speciality: $21.50. 12-inch, Cream & Fruit: $24.50. 12-inch, Speciality: $26.50.

Pot Pies & Quiche: Baby, $8. Nine-Inch, $20.50



  • American Apple

  • Blackberry

  • Blueberry

  • Blueberry Streusel

  • Boozy Blueberry

  • Caramel Apple (brown sugar/butter crumble topping with homemade caramel sauce)

  • Cherry

  • Drunken Apple

  • Dutch Apple (brown sugar/butter crumble topping)

  • Gooseberry

  • Mixed Berry (blueberry, blackberry, raspberry)

  • Old-Fashioned Peach

  • Peach Praline (brown sugar/butter/pecan crumble topping)

  • Peach Raspberry

  • Rhubarb

  • Sour Cream Cherry

  • Sweet Potato

  • Strawberry Rhubarb


  • Almond Joy

  • Almond Rum Raspberry

  • Banana Cream*

  • Banoffee

  • Brown Butter Chess

  • Chocolate Cream*

  • Chocolate Banana*

  • Chocolate Chess

  • Chocolate Key Lime

  • Chocolate Mint*

  • Coconut Cream*

  • French Silk^

  • Key Lime ^

  • Lemon Cream* ^

  • Peanut Butter ^

  • Peanut Butter Chocolate^

  • Pumpkin^

  • Pumpkin Chiffon^

  • Raspberry Key Lime

  • Vanilla Cream

  • White Chocolate Strawberry^

* Give advanced notice if you’d like a meringue topping rather than whipped topping.


  • Chocolate Bourbon Pecan

  • Southern Pecan^

  • German Chocolate ^


  • Pot Pie – Beef

  • Pot Pie – Chicken

  • Quiche - Bacon

  • Quiche - Vegetable

(^)= Available in gluten-free upon request


Featured Pies

Screen Shot 2018-05-08 at 11.50.39 AM.png

White Chocolate Strawberry

Say hello to this fluffy cloud of strawberry whipped cream with a foundation of dense white chocolate cheesecake.

These delicious layers meet in the middle with a sweet spread of baked strawberries. See what Food Network was talking about when they named this pie one of the Best Pies in America.

Screen Shot 2018-05-08 at 11.47.58 AM.png

Mixed Berry

This sweet berry concoction can make the most serious city slicker crave an afternoon on a blueberry farm.

Before you indulge in this scrumptious fruit pie, don't forget to take a picture of the beautiful lattice of Peggy Jean's pie crust. Once you take a bite, you'll understand why our pie crust recipe is too darn good to share. Buy your pie now.

Screen Shot 2018-05-08 at 11.19.22 AM.png

Chocolate Bourbon Pecan

With chocolate, bourbon, and pecan in one pie— what's not to love?

The mix of a crunchy nut topping with a smooth chocolate center is enough to have you thinking about this pie months after your last bite. The hints of bourbon round out this decadent treat and move it from snack level to full-blown dessert. Drop by the shop and see for yourself!

Interested in one of these sweeties?